Matt Carpenter has a mustache

Matt Carpenter joins list of great Yankees mustaches

Yankees: Matt Carpenter mustache loved by MLB fans

Matt Carpenter Discusses His Return for the Playoffs with the Yankees

The Yankees are bringing the mustache back in style - Pinstripe Alley

Fear The Mustache Yankees Ny Yankees Baseball Matt Carpenter Unisex T-Shirt – Teepital – Everyday New Aesthetic Designs

Matt Carpenter, Cardinals agree to 6-year extension

Highlight] Mustache Matt Carpenter ends a 10 pitch at bat vs Shohei Ohtani with a 410 foot blast, the Yankees first leadoff homer of the season, and his third in pinstripes : r/NYYankees

Matt Carpenter brings solid career stats and a nice mustache to Yankees - Newsday

Ray Carsillo on X: Matt Carpenter shaved his beard and now him and Nestor Cortes look like they could be the new Mario and Luigi in a reboot of the Super Mario

The Bat Collector on X: Who wore it better? @yankees Don Mattingly or Matt Carpenter? / X